Taking On Issues - Political Issues and Government Policies

A Hot Discussion Forum on Government Policies and Political Issues

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Election 2016
  • Big Government
  • Healthcare
  • The Other Side
  • What’s New
  • Your Freedom

Why the U.S. Can’t and Shouldn’t Try to ‘Police’ the World

September 21, 2016 By Takingonissues

Anders Fogh Rasmussen essentially wants the U.S. to govern the planet:

In this world of interconnections, it has become a cliché to talk about the “global village.“ But right now, the village is burning, and the neighbors are fighting in the light of the flames. Just as we need a policeman to restore order; we need a firefighter to put out the flames of conflict, and a kind of mayor, smart and sensible, to lead the rebuilding.

Only America can play all these roles, because of all world powers, America alone has the credibility to shape sustainable solutions to these challenges.

Rasmussen’s op-ed makes many familiar mistakes here. For one thing, the entire “village” isn’t burning, and the vast majority of the world is at peace. The need for both “policeman” and “firefighter” is exaggerated to make it seem as if the world will fall into chaos unless the U.S. acts as the author wants, but that isn’t the case. For another, it can’t possibly be the responsibility of any one government to do all of the things mentioned here. No government has the right or authority to do these things, and there is no single government with either the resources or the competence to police the world. Besides, there simply isn’t enough political support for such a role here in the U.S. Even if the U.S. could competently fill the role Rasmussen describes, it would be a mistake to do it.

The costs of such a role are not only exorbitant, but there is an inherent danger in justifying U.S. actions in these terms. Setting the U.S. up as the enforcer of order around the world effectively puts the U.S. above the rules that all states are supposed to follow, and it gives it an excuse to trample on the sovereignty of other states when the enforcer deems it appropriate. Even if our leaders had consistently good judgment, that would create many opportunities for abuse. Since we know our leaders often make poor choices about how and where to intervene, it opens the door to one disaster after another. We also know our government’s “enforcement” is arbitrary and selective, and when its allies and clients break the rules the U.S. is usually helping them or covering for them. Most of the world doesn’t need and presumably doesn’t want a “policeman” that can do what it likes, shield its clients from punishment, and never has to answer to them, and most Americans don’t want their government to act as one.

Of course, it is misleading from the start to think of a major military power as either a police force or a fire brigade. Both of these are typically services under the control of a local government in one’s own community. The U.S. role Rasmussen describes is necessarily very different from that. It isn’t local or accountable to the people being “policed,” and its “policing” is inevitably an intrusion from outside into their affairs. As for being a “mayor,” mayors are normally elected, but most nations around the world haven’t elected and wouldn’t elect the U.S. as “mayor” of the world. Most of the world doesn’t accept the U.S. as its “policeman,” and in quite a few places that role is vehemently denied.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Email, RSS Follow

Related

Subscribe to Taking on Issues

Enter your email address to subscribe to our site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

RSS Political News

  • How Climate Will Change in Cities Across the U.S. February 15, 2019
  • Trump Installed a Giant Golf Simulator Inside the White House February 15, 2019
  • Trump Declares National Emergency for Wall February 15, 2019
  • Judge Orders Alex Jones to Give Deposition in Sandy Hook Case February 15, 2019
  • Zillow's Algorithm Wants to Flip Your House February 15, 2019
  • There Is No National Emergency February 15, 2019
  • Trump on Solid Legal Ground in Declaring Emergency February 15, 2019
  • A Desperate Act of a Desperate Man February 15, 2019
  • A Revealing Two Weeks for Democrats February 15, 2019

Archives

New Featured Articles

  • Report: Justice Department told feds to “stand down” on Dakota Access Pipeline protests
    October 22, 2016

    posted at 5:31 pm on October 22, 2016 by Jazz Shaw A mystery may have been solved in terms of the ongoing protests surrounding the Dakota Access Pipeline in North Dakota. Throughout these demonstrations and incidents of violence centered on the makeshift camps set up on federal land, we’ve been wondering why the federal response […]

    Email, RSS Follow
    […]
  • Star destroyer: Trump’s Walk of Fame star smashed with sledgehammer
    October 26, 2016
    posted at 1:01 pm on October 26, 2016 by John Sexton […]
  • Time Person of the Year shortlist: Trump, Meghan Markle, “Black Panther” director, Parkland kids
    December 10, 2018
    To cleanse the palate, how can a year in which major […]
  • Breaking: Andrew McCabe quits as deputy FBI director, effective immediately; Update: “Removed”?
    January 29, 2018
    My goodness. The timing of this announcement on Memo […]
  • The Tragedy Of Whitney Houston
    May 17, 2018
    I was not a fan of Whitney Houston, the megastar who […]
  • Could The Catholic Church Collapse?
    September 25, 2018
    Grady Means, a Catholic who is a professional business […]
  • Seattle City Council passes plan to turn City Hall lobby into a homeless shelter
    June 19, 2018
    After the recent passage and repeal of the head tax in […]
  • Resisting The Dictatorship Of Relativism
    March 2, 2017
    Thinking further about Elizabeth Stoker […]
  • An infrastructure bill for a new era
    January 29, 2018
    The President needs a new mission in terms of major […]
  • Howard Dean doubles down: Maybe Trump has a coke habit
    September 27, 2016
    posted at 7:21 pm on September 27, 2016 by John Sexton […]
  • ‘Fundamentalism’ & ‘Dialogue’
    April 13, 2018
    Two of the most dodgy words in contemporary religious […]
  • CNN: Hell no, we won’t run Trump’s new ad
    August 15, 2017
    This is the second time this year they’ve […]
  • Hero policeman traded himself for female hostage, was killed by terrorist
    March 24, 2018
    Ed wrote yesterday about the ISIS-inspired terrorist […]
  • Today’s Trump Twitter feud: Trump versus the Carrier union boss over whether he’s saved enough jobs
    December 8, 2016
    posted at 11:21 am on December 8, 2016 by Allahpundit […]
  • Why America Must Put Interests Before Ideals
    August 14, 2018
    American political leaders and foreign policy […]
Copyright © 2019 TakingOnIssues.com

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | About Us