Taking On Issues - Political Issues and Government Policies

A Hot Discussion Forum on Government Policies and Political Issues

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Election 2016
  • Big Government
  • Healthcare
  • The Other Side
  • What’s New
  • Your Freedom
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

NY Times: Maybe the Comey letter didn’t determine the outcome of the election

May 8, 2017 By Takingonissues

posted at 9:21 pm on May 8, 2017 by John Sexton

Did FBI Director James Comey’s letter to Congress announcing an ongoing investigation into Hillary Clinton’s email scandal cost her the election? That’s the argument that FiveThirtyEight’s Nate Silver has made and which Hillary Clinton herself has seemingly endorsed. But what if it’s not true? Today, Nate Cohn of the NY Times makes the case that it’s possible Clinton’s lead had largely evaporated before Comey sent the letter.

Cohn bases this, in part, on a poll of Florida which was completed the day before the letter was released (meaning no one polled knew about it) but not published until after the letter became news. This poll, which seemed an outlier at the time, showed Trump up 4 points, 46 to 42. And though there aren’t a lot of polls like this from the days immediately before the letter, there are a few which suggest Clinton was hitting bottom pre-letter:

The ABC/Washington Post tracking poll conducted over the same period as the Upshot/Siena poll of Florida, for instance, showed Mrs. Clinton’s lead at just two points, down from a double-digit lead after the third debate. That poll was also released after Mr. Comey’s letter.

Most important, the polls taken before the letter were as bad for Mrs. Clinton as those conducted after it. Again, there aren’t many of these polls, but taken at face value there’s a case that Mrs. Clinton had nearly or even completely bottomed out by the time the Comey letter was released. Even if she had not, the trend line heading into the Comey letter was bad enough that there’s no need to assume that the Comey letter was necessary for any additional erosion in her lead.

These polls are consistent with an alternative election narrative in which the Comey letter had no discernible effect on the outcome.

Cohn also cites an investigation into 2016 election polling by the American Association for Public Opinion Research (AAPOR) which found the letter likely impacted Clinton negatively by a couple points but that it’s unclear the effect was lasting:

The evidence for a meaningful effect on the election from the FBI letter is mixed at best. Based on Figure 6, it appears that Clinton’s support started to drop on October 24th or 25th. October 28th falls at roughly the midpoint (not the start) of the slide in Clinton’s support. What’s more, the lag between when interviewing was conducted and when tracking poll results are released means that the slide in Clinton’s support probably began earlier than estimates in Figure 6 suggest. For example, the ABC News/Washington Post estimate of a tied race on October 31 was based on interviews conducted October 28-31. The IBD/TIPP estimates are based on interviews conducted during the six days prior to the date shown. Factoring in this lag, it is reasonable to speculate that Clinton’s slide began as early as October 22 or 23…

We conducted a regression analysis using all national public polls fielded between September 1st and Election Day. This analysis, which controlled for change over time and methodological characteristics of the polls, indicates that the Comey letter had an immediate, negative impact for Clinton on the order of 2 percentage points. The apparent impact did not last, as support for Clinton tended to tick up in the days just prior to the election.

So there’s an argument to be made that Clinton was sliding before the letter and that, even if the letter depressed her numbers a bit more, she rebounded. I expect to see responses to the NY Times piece tomorrow.

Related Posts:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Email, RSS Follow

Related

Subscribe to Taking on Issues

Enter your email address to subscribe to our site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

RSS Political News

  • Greta Thunberg: Times Person of the Year December 12, 2019
  • The Welfare State 'Brezhnev Doctrine' December 12, 2019
  • Understanding the U.S. Economy: Lots of Rotten Jobs December 12, 2019
  • New York's Costly, Quixotic Crusade Against Exxon December 12, 2019
  • How States Are Leading on Climate Action December 12, 2019
  • Smug James Comey Should Cool His Celebratory Jets December 12, 2019
  • The Shamelessness of Bill Barr December 12, 2019
  • How Dems Risk Underminding Suburban Strategy in 2020 December 12, 2019
  • What Iowa Voters' Second-Choice Picks Can Tell Us December 12, 2019

Archives

New Featured Articles

  • Uh-huh: To save water, LA pays folks to tear out lawns that fight smog costing billions
    July 3, 2019

    This would be so California-hilarious if it didn’t affect the health of millions of its citizens. Statistics show that after some years of improvement, mainly nationally, air in the country’s capital of smog, Los Angeles, is deteriorating again. Los Angeles has chronically been the worst place for childhood asthma too. Southern California, the Los Angeles […]

    Email, RSS Follow
  • So Much for Putting Americans First
    August 15, 2019
    Trump’s intervention on Twitter this morning […]
  • Hundreds of 7-Eleven stores had some surprise visitors this week… from ICE
    January 11, 2018
    If you happened to be lining up for coffee yesterday […]
  • The Cost of Weaponizing Aid Deliveries
    July 16, 2019
    The Los Angeles Times reports on the Trump […]
  • The World Doesn’t Need More U.S. Interventionism
    October 18, 2016
    Shadi Hamid thinks the world needs U.S. military […]
  • How to Fix the Swamp Monster Federal Budget
    April 17, 2018
    When I was a young child, I asked my dad to explain […]
  • Great news. Airline fares will be going up again
    January 27, 2018
    Say, did you hear those rumors about airfare wars […]
  • Hmmm: House Dems choose impeachment over #MeToo in Judiciary pick
    December 20, 2017
    A win for seniority, or a blown opportunity? House […]
  • Social engineering: Obama hired behavioral experts to get more people on federal programs
    September 11, 2016
    Personal Liberty Poll Exercise your right to vote. […]
  • Blobfish Basketball Classic: Ted Cruz beats Jimmy Kimmel
    June 17, 2018
    I’ll get right to it. The much ballyhooed […]
  • Greta Thunberg scolds in Madrid: “We have achieved nothing”
    December 7, 2019
    Greta Thunberg arrived in Madrid in time to lecture […]
  • Jared Kushner in Iraq now? He’s a busy guy…
    April 3, 2017
    posted at 8:01 am on April 3, 2017 by Jazz Shaw Is […]
  • No Sh*thole People, Please, We’re Rich Liberals
    February 9, 2018
    “Aren’t we bringing crime?!” […]
  • Let’s Hold The New Congress Accountable, Fast
    December 13, 2010
    Now is the time America.   Now is the time to learn […]
  • Trump says it’s ‘hard to do well’ with ‘zero’ support from Ryan
    October 11, 2016
    WASHINGTON — Republican presidential nominee […]
Copyright © 2019 TakingOnIssues.com

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | About Us