Taking On Issues - Political Issues and Government Policies

A Hot Discussion Forum on Government Policies and Political Issues

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Election 2016
  • Big Government
  • Healthcare
  • The Other Side
  • What’s New
  • Your Freedom

An Alternative to Jihadism

December 20, 2016 By Takingonissues

We can kill terrorists—we can kill nearly all of them—but we cannot kill an idea with drones and lead. Jihadism will not disappear without an alternative ideology, indeed an alternative theology, replacing it in the Middle East. And on that front, the liberal-democratic world seems to have little to offer.

These are neither complicated nor groundbreaking observations. But I’m reminded, after attending the Jamestown Foundation’s Tenth Annual Terrorism Conference, that they must be the foundation of the West’s posture toward the region.

Michael W.S. Ryan, a senior fellow at the Jamestown Foundation, raised this point well. His talk was a fascinating glance to the (thankfully likely) future of a Levant where the Islamic State has no governance. The organization will persist, but without cities or citizens. “ISIS will become a virtual government in exile, looking to regain territory,” he said.

But al-Qaeda never sought rule or territory as ISIS has, so in a sense, our future with a “defeated” ISIS will be a reset: back to the fight against an amorphous coalition of cells, franchises, and organizations united by a shared ideology. Citing a jihadist essayist, Ryan said that local terrorist groups and international terrorist operations are dialectically supportive of each other, “like braided hair.” That is, the material organization and structure of the relationship between “lone wolves” and jihadist groups is less important than the ideological exchange linking them.

How to respond to that radicalizing ideology is “the great challenge to the United States and its allies in the near future,” Ryan said. For jihadists, he explained, the radicalization process begins as a series of attempts to escape and reject the personal status quo, where dignity and respect are absent. That rejection of the previous personal order becomes a rejection of the world order. Radicalizing ideology changes a life, imbues it with meaning, and then demands and promises a changed world too.

To counter terrorism, Ryan said, the United States needs to develop a part-military, part-ideological response system. Material organization and communication must be disrupted as much as possible, but also necessary is a global strategy to address the ideological challenge.

There’s the rub. Attempts to de-radicalize must be tailored to individuals, and will depend on each individual’s path to radicalization and the roots of the discontent and emptiness that prompted it. The better we understand radicalization, the more effectively we can undo its effects.

Ideological inoculation, the widespread prevention of radicalization, is more complicated. That requires a new order that meets the needs of potential radicals—both their material needs and their desire for dignity and respect. Where will such an alternative come from? Complicating all of this is the theological nature and potency of the radicalizing ideology in the Middle East.

When I asked Ryan after his remarks how the West, as a consumer society dealing with its own discontents, would find the resources to offer dignity to those abroad who are willing to seek meaning through violence, he conceded that generally we are not presenting a compelling alternative. “Clearly we do need something more than mammon,” he said. He did, however, hold out hope that some kind of social entrepreneurship—perhaps using technology to connect youth in the United States to youth in the Middle East for conversation—could bridge the gap between the Western world and the Islamic one.

Of course, this is not an alternative ideology, much less a theology. Rather, it is the hope that liberalism will work even at diluting disagreement between whole orders, that conversation and deliberation can overcome conflicting cultural commitments. Perhaps in individual cases it can. But this leaves open the question of ideological inoculation—specifically, of an alternative source of significance to Wahhabi-Salafist jihadism for the Sunni world.

Retired Air Force Gen. Michael V. Hayden, who gave the day’s keynote address, compared—with the right caveats and historical caution—the current state of the whole Islamic world to 16th- and early-17th-century Christendom. He argued that just as the liberal order emerged in the West as a means of reconciling violent religious disagreement, so too must whatever order eventually creates stability in the Middle East develop out of the region and from within the Islamic world. Hayden admitted he could not predict what that would look like, though he did speculate that the situation in the Sunni world specifically might be one where a caliphate is good and necessary—just not this would-be caliphate, meaning ISIS.

If the West can only facilitate conversation, and if the development of a real theological regime must come out of the Sunni world, then American foreign policy in the region should be dictated by humility. Restraining violence, meeting material needs, and protecting minorities are important goals for the role they play in minimizing the desperation that leads to radicalism. But in the end, a Middle East plagued by terrorists is not a place we can simply shoot our way out of.

Micah Meadowcroft is a writer living in Washington, DC.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Email, RSS Follow

Related

Subscribe to Taking on Issues

Enter your email address to subscribe to our site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

RSS Political News

  • How Climate Will Change in Cities Across the U.S. February 15, 2019
  • Trump Installed a Giant Golf Simulator Inside the White House February 15, 2019
  • Trump Declares National Emergency for Wall February 15, 2019
  • Judge Orders Alex Jones to Give Deposition in Sandy Hook Case February 15, 2019
  • Zillow's Algorithm Wants to Flip Your House February 15, 2019
  • There Is No National Emergency February 15, 2019
  • Trump on Solid Legal Ground in Declaring Emergency February 15, 2019
  • A Desperate Act of a Desperate Man February 15, 2019
  • A Revealing Two Weeks for Democrats February 15, 2019

Archives

New Featured Articles

  • Bomb threats made against dozens of Jewish centers and schools nationwide
    January 18, 2017

    posted at 3:01 pm on January 18, 2017 by John Sexton As many as 25 Jewish groups across the U.S. received anonymous bomb threats by telephone Wednesday. This is the second time in two weeks that Jewish community centers and schools have been targeted with such threats. From the Jerusalem Post: Paul Goldenberg, the director […]

    Email, RSS Follow
    […]
  • Department of Education no longer investigating transgender bathroom complaints
    February 13, 2018
    Yet another reversal of an Obama era policy is now in […]
  • Will Bolton Replace McMaster?
    January 29, 2018
    Curt Mills reports that John Bolton is considered a […]
  • BET Founder: I don’t believe Trump is a racist
    November 29, 2016
    posted at 5:01 pm on November 29, 2016 by John Sexton […]
  • Los Angeles is cracking down on… Christopher Columbus?
    August 30, 2017
    As we previously learned from the activists in New […]
  • A libertarian tech revolt
    November 20, 2016
    As the political establishment and Silicon Valley […]
  • Oh look… Putin and Erdogan are getting even cozier and signing a new energy deal
    October 11, 2016
    posted at 12:01 pm on October 11, 2016 by Jazz Shaw […]
  • Stephen Hawking: Messenger from the Universe
    March 16, 2018
    Stephen William Hawking CH CBE FRS FRSA was born on […]
  • Let’s talk about that garbage non-call at the end of the Saints/Rams game
    January 21, 2019
    Is there anything to talk about? Even the man […]
  • ‘Woke’ Librarians Take Their Politics to Another Level
    September 20, 2017
    Everyone knows the old caricature of the local […]
  • Report: Pope Lied About Sexual Abuse
    February 5, 2018
    This Associated Press report is a bombshell: Pope […]
  • Our Bankrupt Approach to North Korea
    November 21, 2017
    Secretary of State Tillerson explained the […]
  • The globalist’s long game — redefine liberty activism as evil ‘populism’
    February 13, 2017
    One of the most favored propaganda tactics of […]
  • Did “fake news” almost start a nuclear war on Christmas Eve? Well… no
    December 26, 2016
    posted at 12:01 pm on December 26, 2016 by Jazz Shaw […]
  • You’re doing what with Lord of the Flies now?
    September 2, 2017
    Did you hear the big Hollywood news? Warner Brothers […]
Copyright © 2019 TakingOnIssues.com

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | About Us